Menu of Diamonds All Star Grille in Meadville, Pennsylvania, USA

Menu Overview

Diamonds All Star Grille, nestled in the heart of Meadville, PA, is a classic diner that expertly balances tradition with a fresh, inviting spirit. From the moment you step inside this cozy spot at 272 Chestnut St Suite D, you can tell this is more than just a place to eat—it’s a community hub curated with care and a passion for quality. The menu reflects that attention, blending comfort food favorites with inventive twists that surprise and satisfy.

The real star of the menu is their Banana Foster French Toast Breakfast. This dish elevates classic French toast with luscious caramelized bananas and a rich sauce, creating a brunch experience that is both indulgent and comforting. Paired with their coffee—hailed by regulars as one of the best cups around—this breakfast feels like a warm embrace on a plate.

For those seeking a hearty lunch, the Country Club Melt is a standout. Served on grilled sourdough with melted American cheese, turkey, and crispy bacon alongside tangy thousand island dressing, it is a perfect balance of smoky, creamy, and savory. It’s a reminder that simple ingredients, when executed flawlessly, are enough to shine.

Meat lovers will appreciate the Ham Steak N Eggs for breakfast, offering a substantial, satisfying start to the day, while the Grilled Chicken Salad in a Bread Bowl presents a clever, hearty way to enjoy fresh greens with tender chicken wrapped in a warm, crusty bread bowl. It’s both practical and pleasing—a true diner comfort food reinvention.

Sandwich options like the All Star Club and the BBQ Chicken Naan Sandwich hit the mark, coming with generous portions and a thoughtfully curated mix of ingredients. The smoky bacon, Swiss cheese, and barbecue sauce on the soft oven-baked flatbread complement each other perfectly and arrive with crispy fries, a classic diner pairing.

The Pot Roast Burger with Fries offers a surprising depth of flavor that melds slow-cooked tenderness with the casual joy of a burger. It is a testament to Diamonds’ skill in crossing comfort foods with innovation. Also noteworthy are the breakfast sides, especially the creamy Mashed Potatoes with Brown Gravy, which pairs delightfully with almost any entree, bringing a down-home feel to your plate.

Diners repeatedly praise the atmosphere and staff, highlighting a friendly and welcoming environment. The energy here feels personal and genuine, amplified by the owners' connection to the history of their location in the Montgomery Wards building. This sense of place enriches the experience, making your meal more than just food but also a narrative worth savoring.

In sum, Diamonds All Star Grille offers a rich menu that honors diner traditions while injecting fresh ideas and top-quality ingredients. Meals are generous, flavors well-balanced, and the service warm—a rare blend that makes this place a true hidden gem in Meadville’s downtown scene. Whether you crave a robust breakfast, a comforting sandwich, or just a perfect cup of coffee, Diamonds All Star Grille delivers with heart and soul.